(Download) "American Equitable Assurance Co. v. Gold" by Supreme Court of North Carolina # eBook PDF Kindle ePub Free
eBook details
- Title: American Equitable Assurance Co. v. Gold
- Author : Supreme Court of North Carolina
- Release Date : January 28, 1959
- Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
- Pages : * pages
- Size : 64 KB
Description
At the commencement of the trial, Judge Snepp first considered the defendants plea in bar. The defendant contended that, since Pharr was a wholly-owned subsidiary of the defendant, it was conducting the business of the defendant; the plaintiff thereby occupied a position tantamount to an employee of the defendant; under the North Carolina Workmens Compensation Act, the only remedy available to such an employee was that provided for pursuant to such act; therefore, this civil action did not lie. After hearing evidence on this question, Judge Snepp entered an order finding that, while Pharr and the defendant had common administrative offices, a common purchasing agent, a common personnel department and a common sales organization, they were nevertheless separate entities for all accounting and tax purposes and, even though they had such common administrative offices, each charged the other for all services actually rendered. Judge Snepp further found that Pharr paid the defendant for the use of the building in question; on 17 June 1964 the plaintiff was performing work under the direction, supervision and control of Pharr; and with respect to this work, the defendant was not conducting the business of Pharr. Based upon his findings of fact, Judge Snepp concluded that the North Carolina Workmens Compensation Act did not prohibit this action. The defendant thereupon appealed from the denial of its plea in bar.